semiopedia.org
CAP Theorem

CAP Theorem

A fundamental principle in distributed systems stating that it is impossible for a distributed data store to simultaneously provide more than two out of three guarantees: Consistency, Availability, and Partition tolerance.

CAP Theorem

The CAP theorem, introduced by computer scientist Eric Brewer in 2000, represents a crucial concept in distributed systems design. It asserts that any networked shared-data system can only guarantee two of three desirable properties:

Core Properties

Consistency (C)

  • All nodes see the same data at the same time
  • Every read receives the most recent write
  • Strongly aligned with ACID Properties in traditional databases
  • Requires all nodes to be in sync before proceeding

Availability (A)

  • Every request receives a response
  • The system remains operational at all times
  • No guarantee that the response contains the most recent data
  • Connected to High Availability concepts

Partition Tolerance (P)

  • The system continues to operate despite network partitions
  • Essential for distributed computing systems
  • Handles communication breakdowns between nodes
  • Cannot be avoided in real-world distributed systems

Practical Implications

In practice, because network partitions cannot be prevented in distributed systems, designers must choose between:

  1. CP (Consistency/Partition Tolerance)

    • Prioritizes data consistency
    • May become temporarily unavailable
    • Examples: HBase, ZooKeeper

  2. AP (Availability/Partition Tolerance)

    • Prioritizes system availability
    • Accepts eventual consistency
    • Examples: Cassandra, DynamoDB

Modern Interpretations

Recent discussions have evolved the understanding of CAP:

  • It's more nuanced than a simple "pick two" choice
  • Systems can offer different guarantees for different operations
  • PACELC Theorem extends CAP to consider latency tradeoffs
  • Modern systems often implement eventual consistency models

Design Considerations

When architecting distributed systems, engineers must:

  1. Understand their specific use case requirements
  2. Consider the nature of network partitions in their environment
  3. Evaluate the cost of inconsistency vs. unavailability
  4. Implement appropriate fault tolerance mechanisms

Industry Impact

The CAP theorem has profoundly influenced:

Limitations and Criticism

Some experts argue that CAP:

  • Oversimplifies complex distributed system tradeoffs
  • Doesn't address important properties like latency
  • May lead to suboptimal design decisions if applied too rigidly
  • Should be considered alongside other principles like BASE Properties

The CAP theorem remains a foundational concept in distributed systems, though its application continues to evolve with new technologies and architectural patterns. Understanding its implications is crucial for anyone working with distributed systems or designing scalable applications.